Autoren

Jessica Thomas

Senior Associate

Read More

Lucy Waddicor

Associate

Read More
Autoren

Jessica Thomas

Senior Associate

Read More

Lucy Waddicor

Associate

Read More

8. März 2022

Disputes Quick Read – 61 von 63 Insights

Disputes Quick Read: Climate change litigation update

  • Quick read

R (Cox, Loach, Sweeden) v Oil and Gas Authority

In February 2022, the High Court handed down its judgment in the judicial review of the Oil and Gas Authority's (OGA) Strategy for the ongoing oil and gas exploration in the North Sea – as mentioned in our January update.

The strategy pursued the OGA's statutory objective of "maximising the economic recovery of UK petroleum" (MER). The claimants challenged the OGA's strategy on two grounds:

  • First, that the strategy didn't benefit the UK economy because of favourable tax treatment to oil and gas companies, in particular negative tax flows to such companies. Cockerill J dismissed this ground, finding that the interpretation of MER was a matter for the OGA (with its specialist understanding and judgment), not the Court.
  • Second, that the strategy was irrational because it would lead to more extraction of petroleum, resulting in more emissions and more stranded assets, and this conflicted with the government's net zero target. Cockerill J dismissed this ground too, noting that it might be different if the OGA had paid no regard to climate change. But that wasn't the case; the OGA had taken climate change into account in various ways when devising the strategy and therefore hadn't acted irrationally.

Comment

Climate change litigation continues to arise in the judicial review process in England, even though there has been no (notable) success so far. However, these judicial reviews are gaining some traction in the courts, with permission being granted in this case, and a detailed judgment being given in another recent case, albeit permission was refused in that instance.

In March 2022, ClientEarth and Friends of the Earth were granted permission for a judicial review of the government's net zero strategy. Specifically, the applicants claimed that the net zero strategy is insufficient to meet the net zero target, in breach of the government's duty under the Climate Change Act. ClientEarth also claims that the government's approach risks needing more drastic measures in the future, disproportionately affecting young people's right to life and family life.

One hurdle claimants are likely to face is that public bodies' statutory duties in this area are often "process duties" (as Cockerill J put it in the OGA case); they're required to have regard to various climate change factors, but the question of how to balance those factors and others is ultimately a matter for them.

It's also noteworthy that at the permission stage of the OGA case, some scepticism was expressed about Ground 2 and permission was only granted for it because of its links with Ground 1. We may see more of this in the future: climate-focussed issues bolstered by other, more sound legal arguments.

Whether cases against public bodies ultimately succeed in court, they bring publicity to the cause, reputational risk to the defendants, and may well help to keep climate change high on the government's agenda. They won't be going away any time soon.

In dieser Serie

Disputes & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: Ethereum Merge - what legal issues arise?

22. September 2022

von Ben Jones, Emma Allen

Kryptowährungen, Blockchain und Distributed-Ledger-Technologie

Disputes Quick Read: New obligations on cryptobusinesses to report under the UK sanctions regime

9. August 2022

von Nick Maday, Katie Fry-Paul

Disputes & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: New gateway for serving Norwich Pharmacal Orders and Bankers Trust orders out of the jurisdiction

Welcome news for those pursuing fraud claims in the English Courts

28. July 2022

von Emma Allen, Samantha Brendish

Disputes & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: Key changes to the Disclosure Pilot Scheme

13. September 2021

von Edward Spencer

Disputes & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: UK Supreme Court rules on the territorial extent of the SFO's powers

26. February 2021

von mehreren Autoren

Disputes & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: Care required when drafting SPA claim notices

23. September 2020

von mehreren Autoren

Disputes & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: The importance of proper service

26. May 2020

von Edward Spencer

Disputes & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: The latest on Unexplained Wealth Orders

7. May 2020

von mehreren Autoren

Coronavirus

Disputes Quick Read: COVID-19 and supply chain disruption – key issues

9. April 2020

von mehreren Autoren

Disputes & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: Tomlin Orders – ensuring the confidentiality of settlement terms

27. April 2020

von mehreren Autoren

Coronavirus

Disputes Quick Read: Embracing remote hearings – the experience to date

26. March 2020

von mehreren Autoren

Disputes & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: Commercial Court's arbitral power shift

21. February 2020

von Andrew Howell

Disputes & Investigations

Disputes quick read: pilot error?

13. February 2020

von Andrew Howell

Disputes & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: Privilege waiver warning

2. July 2020

von Tim Strong, Georgina Jones

Disputes & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: Dealing in crypto? Be careful what you call it

7. April 2022

von mehreren Autoren

Call To Action Arrow Image

Newsletter-Anmeldung

Wählen Sie aus unserem Angebot Ihre Interessen aus!

Jetzt abonnieren
Jetzt abonnieren

Related Insights

Disputes & Investigations

European parliament calls for EU to exit the Energy Charter Treaty

6. Dezember 2022

von mehreren Autoren

Klicken Sie hier für Details
Disputes & Investigations

Four EU Member States announce exit from ECT in pursuit of their climate change agendas

25. Oktober 2022

von Jessica Thomas und Karel Daele

Klicken Sie hier für Details
Disputes & Investigations

EU Commission interprets CETA's investment protection provisions to advance its climate change agenda

11. Oktober 2022

von Jessica Thomas und Karel Daele

Klicken Sie hier für Details