Autor

Georgina Jones

Senior Associate

Read More
Autor

Georgina Jones

Senior Associate

Read More

2. Juni 2020

Disputes Quick Read – 75 von 88 Insights

Disputes Quick Read: Court stays evictions during COVID-19 – is this lawful?

  • QUICK READ

A number of practice directions have been introduced to temporarily modify the court's procedural rules, the Civil Procedure Rules (CPR), to ensure that the courts can operate as effectively as possible during the coronavirus pandemic. We have been tracking these amendments here.

One such amendment, Practice direction 51Z, Stay of Possession Proceedings – Coronavirus (PD51Z), recently came under challenge for allegedly being implemented without proper legal authority.

PD51Z introduced a 90-day stay on all possession proceedings brought under Part 55 of the CPR and all proceedings for the enforcement of possession orders. Paragraph 2(A) of PD51Z sets out a limited number of exceptions, including applications for case management directions which are agreed by the parties.

The challenge to the validity of PD51Z was made by Mr Arkin (a fixed charge receiver) in possession proceedings Arkin v Marshall [2020] EWCA Civ 620, in which the parties had agreed case management directions prior to the implementation of PD51Z.

Mr Arkin argued that PD51Z was not a "pilot scheme" as required for practice directions implemented under CPR 51.2 to modify existing rules, and that the stay inhibited access to justice in contravention of Article 6 of the ECHR.

In its judgment given on 11 May 2020, the Court of Appeal rejected the challenge in its entirety, because:

  • The stay was being trialled as a measure to protect public health by reducing evictions, and to reduce the burden on the court system by delaying applications for possession (approximately 138,000 possession claims are made each year in the county courts). As the stay could lead to a permanent rule, it constituted a "pilot scheme" under CPR51.2.
  • Any delay to proceedings would not cause any real risk to access to justice, and was justifiable under the circumstances.
  • While judges retain "theoretical" power to lift the stay, the Court of Appeal was strongly of the view that they should only do so in the most exceptional circumstances, such as if the stay posed a risk to public health. This was clearly not such a case.

Where does this leave parties who have agreed case management directions?

The carve-out is limited to the endorsement of agreed directions. Therefore, if the stay applies, parties are not required to carry out the agreed directions during the stay period, but can do so voluntarily. However, any applications to amend the directions order or to remedy compliance issues would have to wait until the stay has expired.

Although the impact of PD51Z itself has not been without controversy, we think this is the right approach. The purpose of practice directions is to enable the CPR to be amended without the need for further legislation, which provides a degree of flexibility to respond to a development – or an entirely unpredictable pandemic – as it arises. The alternative of requiring Parliament to legislate for every procedural amendment to be trialled would be simply unworkable.

Furthermore, the reasoning expressed by the Court of Appeal in Arkin has now been followed and extended in Okoro v London Borough of Hackney [2020] EWCA Civ 681. The judgment in this case confirms that PD51Z also applies to appeals from possession orders that have already been made. In view of the "blanket" character of the stay, this result is perhaps unsurprising.

In dieser Serie

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Internal investigations - raising the bar

1. May 2024

von Andrew Howell

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

New SFO Director announces bold plans to tackle fraud

21. March 2024

von mehreren Autoren

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

What are the litigation trends for 2024?

1. February 2024

von Katie Chandler, Emma Allen

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

ClientEarth v FCA: Challenging Regulator Decisions

12. February 2024

von Tim Strong, Nicole Baldev

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

First of its kind judicial guidance on the use of AI in the courts

14. December 2023

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Court of Appeal confirms mandatory ADR is here to stay

4. December 2023

von Stephanie High, Elizabeth Montpetit

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

The use of AI in Trial Witness Statements post-PD 57AC

23. October 2023

von mehreren Autoren

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Law Commission's report on digital assets: what's next?

2. October 2023

von Georgina Jones, Claudia Blofeld

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Failure to prevent fraud – a new offence?

14. August 2023

von mehreren Autoren

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Supreme Court rules that APP fraud victims cannot rely on Quincecare Duty

4. August 2023

von mehreren Autoren

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: ClientEarth refused permission to pursue directors of Shell

1. June 2023

von mehreren Autoren

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

CJC costs review – what will change?

1. June 2023

von James Bryden, Helen Robinson

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Embargoed judgments – dos and don'ts

16. May 2023

von Stephanie High

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read – developments in the fixed costs regime

3. May 2023

von James Bryden

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: Service by email – are the rules any clearer?

20. April 2023

von James Bryden

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: Breaking the north/south divide?

5. April 2023

von Saleem Fazal MBE, Tom Charnley

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: What are the litigation trends for 2023?

2. March 2023

von Katie Chandler, Emma Allen

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: Why the UK should join the Hague Judgments Convention 2019

8. February 2023

von Jessie Prynne

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: A new approach to giving evidence? WhatsApp with that?

3. October 2022

von Gemma Broughall

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: Ethereum Merge - what legal issues arise?

22. September 2022

von Ben Jones, Emma Allen

Kryptowährungen, Blockchain und Distributed-Ledger-Technologie

Disputes Quick Read: New obligations on cryptobusinesses to report under the UK sanctions regime

9. August 2022

von Nick Maday

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: Disclosure - What information can be redacted?

25. July 2022

von Edward Spencer

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: what claims exist when a smart contract is breached?

6. July 2022

von Emma Allen

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: New gateway for serving Norwich Pharmacal Orders and Bankers Trust orders out of the jurisdiction

Welcome news for those pursuing fraud claims in the English Courts

28. July 2022

von Emma Allen, Samantha Brendish

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: Disclosure Pilot Scheme – here to stay

21. July 2022

von Edward Spencer

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: Judicial Review and Courts Act 2022 – now in force

17. June 2022

von Stephanie High

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: ClientEarth v Shell – climate change litigation shifts focus to UK companies

31. March 2022

von mehreren Autoren

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: High Court rules that failure to provide adequate data security is not a positive act

21. September 2021

von mehreren Autoren

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: Key changes to the Disclosure Pilot Scheme

13. September 2021

von Edward Spencer

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: Will the courts change forever post-COVID?

26. May 2021

von David de Ferrars

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: Care required when drafting SPA claim notices

23. September 2020

von mehreren Autoren

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: Why the modernised LCIA rules are a welcome update

7. October 2020

von Nick Storrs

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: The importance of proper service

26. May 2020

von Edward Spencer

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Disputes quick read: Mandatory changes to Statements of Truth

18. May 2020

von Katie Chandler

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: The latest on Unexplained Wealth Orders

7. May 2020

von Andrew Howell, Georgina Jones

Coronavirus

Disputes Quick Read: COVID-19 and supply chain disruption – key issues

9. April 2020

von mehreren Autoren

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: Tomlin Orders – ensuring the confidentiality of settlement terms

27. April 2020

von mehreren Autoren

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: A different approach to witness evidence

11. March 2020

von James Bryden

Coronavirus

Disputes Quick Read: Embracing remote hearings – the experience to date

26. March 2020

von mehreren Autoren

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Disputes quick read: climate change activism by litigation

26. February 2020

von Tim Strong, Andrew Howell

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: Commercial Court's arbitral power shift

21. February 2020

von Andrew Howell

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Disputes quick read: pilot error?

13. February 2020

von Andrew Howell

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: Privilege waiver warning

2. July 2020

von Tim Strong, Georgina Jones

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: The contra proferentem rule reconsidered?

21. July 2020

von Katie Chandler, Stephanie High

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: Disclosure – out of control?

10. November 2021

von Alexandra Boreham, Edward Spencer

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: Climate change litigation – what's the latest?

10. January 2022

von Tim Strong, Jessica Thomas

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: Climate change litigation update

8. March 2022

von Jessica Thomas, Lucy Waddicor

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: Dealing in crypto? Be careful what you call it

7. April 2022

von mehreren Autoren

Call To Action Arrow Image

Newsletter-Anmeldung

Wählen Sie aus unserem Angebot Ihre Interessen aus!

Jetzt abonnieren
Jetzt abonnieren

Related Insights

Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Law Commission's report on digital assets: what's next?

2. Oktober 2023
Quick read

von Georgina Jones und Claudia Blofeld

Klicken Sie hier für Details
Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Do Bitcoin developers owe fiduciary duties to Bitcoin owners?

23. Februar 2023
Briefing

von mehreren Autoren

Klicken Sie hier für Details
Rechtsstreitigkeiten & Investigations

Disputes Quick Read: A cautionary tale – settlement agreement (un)wittingly releases all claims for fraud

13. Februar 2023
Briefing

von Georgina Jones und Ella Bazini

Klicken Sie hier für Details