31. März 2022
Disputes Quick Read – 49 von 95 Insights
In January 2022, we anticipated that while governments and public authorities have so far been the primary targets for climate change litigation in the UK, companies could be next in the firing line. That shift in focus now appears to be taking place: earlier this month, ClientEarth announced it intends to take legal action against Shell's Board of Directors, by way of a 'derivative' claim on the company's behalf.
In its capacity as a shareholder of Shell, ClientEarth alleges that the directors are mismanaging the risks of climate change through an inadequate energy plan and that this leaves Shell's long-term commercial viability and competitiveness in danger due to the government's Net Zero Strategy. ClientEarth say that this is in breach of the directors' statutory duties to: (i) promote the success of the company; and (ii) exercise reasonable care, skill and diligence (sections 172 and 174 of the Companies Act 2006).
ClientEarth will need the UK court's permission to bring its claim against Shell's directors. In the absence of obvious egregious conduct on the part of the directors, ClientEarth may struggle to get that permission. For example, the court might decide that the question of Shell falling behind in the transition to net zero is a matter for commercial judgement for the directors, rather than a matter justifying the court's intervention.
Despite this, climate change activism by litigation in the UK is clearly stepping up a gear. ClientEarth's proposed action is the first (notable) attempt in the UK courts to hold directors personally liable for failure to properly prepare for transition to net zero. Their announcement could be the start of a shift in focus for climate activists and shareholders alike.
All companies facing climate-related financial risks should bear in mind that activist shareholders will be watching how these risks are managed and may consider a similar kind of derivative claim against the directors if the company's strategy falls short.
This also isn't the first example of climate change activists becoming shareholders of some of the world's 'carbon majors' in order to then bring a shareholder action against the company in whom they hold shares: ClientEarth brought a successful shareholder action in Poland against energy company Enea in October 2018.
In that claim, they challenged Enea's intention to build a new coal-fired power plant, arguing that the new plant would quickly become a stranded asset and was therefore an unjustifiable financial risk to shareholders. The Polish Court agreed and, in August 2019, the resolution authorising construction of the plant was held to be legally invalid.
Whether or not ClientEarth is granted permission, its latest claim has already seen a measure of success through wide-spread press coverage. This coverage has:
ClientEarth is also using the proposed claim to actively seek support from other shareholders in Shell, particularly institutional shareholders, which ClientEarth suggests are themselves under a fiduciary duty to support the claim and compel Shell to change its strategy. Regardless of the legal merits on which the claim might be based, the reputational impact could be enough to push Shell's Board to act in a way which vindicates ClientEarth's objectives.
Reach out to a member of our Disputes and Investigations team if you want to know more about what this might mean for you.
30. October 2024
von mehreren Autoren
15. October 2024
von Emma Allen, Andrew Spencer
16. July 2024
von Tim Strong, Kate Hamblin
5. July 2024
von Stuart Broom, Tom Charnley
21. March 2024
von Emma Allen, Amy Cheng
1. February 2024
von Katie Chandler, Emma Allen
12. February 2024
von Tim Strong, Nicole Baldev
14. December 2023
13. December 2023
23. October 2023
von mehreren Autoren
17. October 2023
12. September 2023
von Tom Charnley
14. August 2023
von mehreren Autoren
4. August 2023
von mehreren Autoren
21. July 2023
10. July 2023
1. June 2023
von mehreren Autoren
3. May 2023
von James Bryden
20. April 2023
von James Bryden
8. March 2023
2. March 2023
von Katie Chandler, Emma Allen
14. February 2023
13. February 2023
8. February 2023
von Jessie Prynne
19. January 2023
3. October 2022
von Gemma Broughall
22. September 2022
von Ben Jones, Emma Allen
9. August 2022
von Nick Maday
25. July 2022
von Edward Spencer
6. July 2022
von Emma Allen
Welcome news for those pursuing fraud claims in the English Courts
28. July 2022
21. July 2022
von Edward Spencer
27. July 2022
von Stuart Broom
29. July 2022
von Jess Thomas, Lucy Waddicor
17. June 2022
von Stephanie High
13. June 2022
von Edward Spencer
26. May 2022
31. May 2022
von mehreren Autoren
4. April 2022
5. April 2022
von Stephanie High
31. March 2022
von mehreren Autoren
21. September 2021
von mehreren Autoren
13. September 2021
von Edward Spencer
6. September 2021
von Stephanie High
2. August 2021
21. July 2021
15. July 2021
von Jess Thomas
26. May 2021
von David de Ferrars
5. May 2021
von Stephen O'Grady
21. April 2021
von Stephanie High
31. March 2021
26. February 2021
von Tim Strong
24. February 2021
20. January 2021
von Stephanie High
12. January 2021
von Tim Strong
23. November 2020
16. October 2020
23. September 2020
von mehreren Autoren
7. October 2020
von Nick Storrs
26. May 2020
von Edward Spencer
12. May 2020
18. May 2020
von Katie Chandler
9. April 2020
von mehreren Autoren
15. April 2020
27. April 2020
von mehreren Autoren
21. April 2020
von Stephanie High
11. March 2020
von James Bryden
17. March 2020
von Stuart Broom
26. March 2020
von mehreren Autoren
26. February 2020
von Tim Strong, Andrew Howell
21. February 2020
von Andrew Howell
2. June 2020
von Georgina Jones
16. June 2020
von Georgina Jones
2. July 2020
von Tim Strong, Georgina Jones
9. July 2020
21. July 2020
3. December 2021
24. November 2021
von Stuart Broom
8. October 2021
von Katie Chandler
10. January 2022
von Tim Strong, Jess Thomas
20. January 2022
8. March 2022
von Jess Thomas, Lucy Waddicor
22. March 2022
7. April 2022
von mehreren Autoren
von Karel Daele und Jess Thomas
von mehreren Autoren
von mehreren Autoren