15 avril 2020
Disputes Quick Read – 25 de 57 Publications
As a result of the COVID-19 pandemic restrictions, we are seeing the UK courts grappling with various applications to adjourn upcoming trials. So far, it seems that the courts are willing to embrace remote hearings to avoid adjournments – not only for simple cases, but also complex disputes. We think this is the right approach.
In a decision handed down recently, the High Court ordered the parties to a £250m claim listed for a 5-week trial in June – which involves four live witnesses of fact and 13 expert witnesses – to cooperate in exploring ways in which the case could be heard in a fully remote trial.
The claimants had sought to have the claim adjourned, arguing (among other things) that the technological challenge was too great. The judge was not convinced. He noted that since 16 March 2020, there have been at least two examples of fully remote trials taking place (albeit on smaller scales) and the technological challenges were not so great as to make it appropriate to adjourn now.
The judge emphasised that cooperation and planning was essential if a remote trial was going to be possible, and that he would expect any proposed system to be subjected to robust testing first, both to ensure adequate video and audio quality, and also to confirm that documents could be displayed quickly.
We welcome the court's approach. Complex commercial cases can take many years to reach trial, and the court and the litigants should cooperate to explore options in scenarios where adjournment can potentially be avoided through a remote hearing. Live trials will ordinarily be much preferred, but it will be interesting to see whether remote hearings remain a procedural option once the pandemic has run its course.
par plusieurs auteurs
par plusieurs auteurs
par Edward Spencer
par Stephanie High
par Jessica Thomas
par David de Ferrars
par Stephen O'Grady
par Stephanie High
par plusieurs auteurs
par Stephanie High
par Tim Strong
par plusieurs auteurs
par Nick Storrs
par Edward Spencer
par Katie Chandler
par plusieurs auteurs
par plusieurs auteurs
par plusieurs auteurs
par Stephanie High
par James Bryden
par Stuart Broom
par plusieurs auteurs
par Tim Strong, Andrew Howell
par Andrew Howell
par Georgina Jones
par Georgina Jones
par Tim Strong, Georgina Jones
par Stuart Broom
par Katie Chandler
par Tim Strong, Jessica Thomas
par plusieurs auteurs
par Stephanie High
par Emma Allen
par Edward Spencer
par Stuart Broom
Welcome news for those pursuing fraud claims in the English Courts
par Nick Maday, Katie Fry-Paul
par Andrew Howell et Jessie Prynne
par Andrew Howell et Georgina Jones
par Andrew Howell et Georgina Jones