10 novembre 2021
Disputes Quick Read – 39 de 57 Publications
Disputes Quick Read: Disclosure – out of control?
At a recent disclosure hearing in Quartz Assets LLC and another v Kestrel Coal Midco Pty Ltd [2021] EWHC 2675 (Comm), the claimant sought an order that the defendant extend its disclosure searches for pre-contractual negotiations and correspondence to include documents held by a third party (TP). The defendant agreed that the documents would be relevant but resisted disclosure as the documents were not in its control.
Background
The second claimant and the defendant entered into a mezzanine subscription agreement in 2018. In the lead up to the agreement, TP was communicating with potential senior and mezzanine investors (including the second claimant) about possible financing and negotiating the terms of the agreement on behalf of the defendant pursuant to a retainer (to which the defendant was not a party).
There was a 'no agency' clause in the retainer, which provided that TP did not have authority to take action or sign any document on behalf of the defendant or otherwise bind it in any respect.
The disclosure order
The Judge found that:
- the 'no agency' clause did not prevent TP from potentially altering the defendant's legal relations by making representations during negotiations
- there was therefore an agency relationship between TP and the defendant, even though the defendant was not a party to the retainer and was not paying TP's fees
- the defendant therefore had a legal right to access documents held by TP which were created during the agency relationship, in particular whilst TP was negotiating with the second claimant and other potential investors
- consequently, the documents held by TP were deemed to be within defendant's 'control' within the meaning of CPR 31.8 (where a party's documents are in the hands of a servant or agent).
The judgment provides useful guidance on agency in the context of disclosure and is a helpful reminder that parties should consider at an early stage whether any third parties might hold relevant documents which could be deemed within either party's control.
The judgment also gives insight of how the court will approach applications under the disclosure pilot scheme. Central to the decisions are the usual principles of reasonableness and proportionality, but close attention will be paid to the agreed issues for disclosure, which is one of the key new requirements introduced by the disclosure pilot.
Find out more
To discuss the issues raised in this article in more detail, please reach out to a member of our Disputes & Investigations team.
Dans cette série
Disputes Quick Read: ClientEarth v Shell – climate change litigation shifts focus to UK companies
par plusieurs auteurs
Disputes Quick Read: High Court rules that failure to provide adequate data security is not a positive act
Disputes Quick Read: Judicial Review and Courts Bill – unpacking the UK government's proposed amendments
par Stephanie High
Disputes Quick Read: Will litigants be compelled to participate in alternative dispute resolution?
Disputes Quick Read: Freezing injunctions – maximum custodial sentence imposed for breach
Disputes Quick Read: The online future of civil justice – the end of the legal profession or the end of legal drudgery?
par Jessica Thomas
Disputes Quick Read: Will the courts change forever post-COVID?
par David de Ferrars
Disputes Quick Read: One Blackfriars administrators cleared of misfeasance
par Stephen O'Grady
Disputes Quick Read: Not your prerogative – the Independent Review of Administrative Law reports its recommendations on judicial review
par Stephanie High
Disputes Quick Read: Amendments to the Disclosure Pilot Scheme – a step in the right direction
Disputes Quick Read: UK Supreme Court rules on the territorial extent of the SFO's powers
par plusieurs auteurs
Disputes Quick Read: No dropping anchor – parent company liability for environmental claims
Disputes Quick Read: What lawyers need to know about new witness statement preparation rules
par Stephanie High
Disputes Quick Read: Should you still choose the English courts to have jurisdiction in your international contracts after Brexit?
par Tim Strong
Disputes Quick Read: Privilege lost in the EU post-Brexit (with exceptions)
Disputes Quick Read: Law on interest applicable to US dollar awards reaffirmed
Disputes Quick Read: Care required when drafting SPA claim notices
par plusieurs auteurs
Disputes Quick Read: Why the modernised LCIA rules are a welcome update
par Nick Storrs
Disputes quick read: Mandatory changes to Statements of Truth
par Katie Chandler
Disputes Quick Read: The latest on Unexplained Wealth Orders
par plusieurs auteurs
Disputes Quick Read: COVID-19 and supply chain disruption – key issues
par plusieurs auteurs
Disputes Quick Read: High Court orders parties to explore options for 5-week remote trial
Disputes Quick Read: Tomlin Orders – ensuring the confidentiality of settlement terms
par plusieurs auteurs
Disputes Quick Read: UK's OFSI fines Standard Chartered Bank £20 million for sanctions breaches
par Stephanie High
Disputes Quick Read: A different approach to witness evidence
par James Bryden
Disputes Quick Read: Coronavirus - a growth in virtual courts?
par Stuart Broom
Disputes Quick Read: Embracing remote hearings – the experience to date
par plusieurs auteurs
Disputes quick read: climate change activism by litigation
par Tim Strong, Andrew Howell
Disputes Quick Read: Commercial Court's arbitral power shift
par Andrew Howell
Disputes Quick Read: Court stays evictions during COVID-19 – is this lawful?
par Georgina Jones
Disputes Quick Read: Will the civil justice system change forever post COVID-19?
par Georgina Jones
Disputes Quick Read: Privilege waiver warning
par Tim Strong, Georgina Jones
Disputes Quick Read: Retailers reign supreme in Visa and Mastercard proceedings
Disputes Quick Read: Scope of duty and the SAAMCo counterfactual following Manchester Building Society
Disputes Quick Read: Facilitating transactions in cryptoassets - Lord Leggatt and the point of commercial law
par Stuart Broom
Disputes Quick Read: Privy Council clarifies the law on freezing injunctions in aid of foreign proceedings
par Katie Chandler
Disputes Quick Read: Climate change litigation – what's the latest?
par Tim Strong, Jessica Thomas
Disputes Quick Read: Court decisions on the Disclosure Pilot Scheme – the 2021 roundup
par Natalia Faekova
Disputes Quick Read: Assumption of responsibility - tax schemes and investors
Don't lose your keys: Bitcoin developers do not have a duty to assist owners in recovering lost cryptocurrency
Disputes Quick Read: Dealing in crypto? Be careful what you call it
par plusieurs auteurs
Disputes Quick Read: ENRC prevails in claim against former solicitor
Disputes Quick Read: Judicial Review and Courts Act 2022 – now in force
par Stephanie High
Disputes Quick Read: what claims exist when a smart contract is breached?
par Emma Allen
Disputes Quick Read: Climate change litigation – successful challenge to government's Net Zero Strategy
Disputes Quick Read: Defining the duty - the limits of the responsibility assumed by professionals
par Stuart Broom
Disputes Quick Read: Disclosure - What information can be redacted?
par Lizzie Hancock
Disputes Quick Read: New gateway for serving Norwich Pharmacal Orders and Bankers Trust orders out of the jurisdiction
Welcome news for those pursuing fraud claims in the English Courts
Disputes Quick Read: New obligations on cryptobusinesses to report under the UK sanctions regime
par Nick Maday, Katie Fry-Paul
Related Insights
Disputes Quick Read: Amendments to the Disclosure Pilot Scheme – a step in the right direction
par Tim Strong et Alexandra Boreham