Auteurs
Alexandra Boreham

Alexandra Boreham

Collaborateur

Read More
Edward Spencer

Edward Spencer

Senior counsel

Read More
Auteurs
Alexandra Boreham

Alexandra Boreham

Collaborateur

Read More
Edward Spencer

Edward Spencer

Senior counsel

Read More

10 novembre 2021

Disputes Quick Read – 39 de 49 Publications

Disputes Quick Read: Disclosure – out of control?

  • Quick read

At a recent disclosure hearing in Quartz Assets LLC and another v Kestrel Coal Midco Pty Ltd [2021] EWHC 2675 (Comm), the claimant sought an order that the defendant extend its disclosure searches for pre-contractual negotiations and correspondence to include documents held by a third party (TP). The defendant agreed that the documents would be relevant but resisted disclosure as the documents were not in its control. 

Background

The second claimant and the defendant entered into a mezzanine subscription agreement in 2018. In the lead up to the agreement, TP was communicating with potential senior and mezzanine investors (including the second claimant) about possible financing and negotiating the terms of the agreement on behalf of the defendant pursuant to a retainer (to which the defendant was not a party).  

There was a 'no agency' clause in the retainer, which provided that TP did not have authority to take action or sign any document on behalf of the defendant or otherwise bind it in any respect. 

The disclosure order

The Judge found that:

  • the 'no agency' clause did not prevent TP from potentially altering the defendant's legal relations by making representations during negotiations
  • there was therefore an agency relationship between TP and the defendant, even though the defendant was not a party to the retainer and was not paying TP's fees
  • the defendant therefore had a legal right to access documents held by TP which were created during the agency relationship, in particular whilst TP was negotiating with the second claimant and other potential investors
  • consequently, the documents held by TP were deemed to be within defendant's 'control' within the meaning of CPR 31.8 (where a party's documents are in the hands of a servant or agent).

The judgment provides useful guidance on agency in the context of disclosure and is a helpful reminder that parties should consider at an early stage whether any third parties might hold relevant documents which could be deemed within either party's control.

The judgment also gives insight of how the court will approach applications under the disclosure pilot scheme. Central to the decisions are the usual principles of reasonableness and proportionality, but close attention will be paid to the agreed issues for disclosure, which is one of the key new requirements introduced by the disclosure pilot.

Find out more 

To discuss the issues raised in this article in more detail, please reach out to a member of our Disputes & Investigations team.

Dans cette série

Résolution des litiges

Disputes Quick Read: Care required when drafting SPA claim notices

QUICK READ

par plusieurs auteurs

Résolution des litiges

Disputes Quick Read: The latest on Unexplained Wealth Orders

QUICK READ

par plusieurs auteurs

Résolution des litiges

Disputes Quick Read: Tomlin Orders – ensuring the confidentiality of settlement terms

QUICK READ

par plusieurs auteurs

Résolution des litiges

Disputes quick read: pilot error?

par Andrew Howell

Résolution des litiges

Disputes Quick Read: Dealing in crypto? Be careful what you call it

Briefing

par plusieurs auteurs

Call To Action Arrow Image

Latest insights in your inbox

Subscribe to newsletters on topics relevant to you.

Subscribe
Subscribe

Related Insights

Résolution des litiges

Disputes Quick Read: Court decisions on the Disclosure Pilot Scheme – the 2021 roundup

20 janvier 2022
Briefing

par Edward Spencer et Natalia Faekova

Cliquer ici pour en savoir plus
Résolution des litiges

Disputes Quick Read: High Court rules that failure to provide adequate data security is not a positive act

21 septembre 2021
Quick read

par plusieurs auteurs

Cliquer ici pour en savoir plus
Résolution des litiges

Disputes Quick Read: Key changes to the Disclosure Pilot Scheme

13 septembre 2021
Quick read

par Edward Spencer

Cliquer ici pour en savoir plus