4 avril 2022
Disputes Quick Read – 53 de 101 Publications
In the latest chapter in the high profile Tulip litigation (Tulip Trading Limited v Bitcoin Association for BSV and others [2022] EWHC 667 (Ch)), the High Court found that the Defendant software developers did not owe any fiduciary or tortious duties to the claimant, Tulip Trading Limited ("Tulip"), to help it in regaining control and use of its Bitcoin.
The Bitcoin in question was said to be worth U$4.5 billion and had allegedly been subject to a hack that resulted in the deletion of the private keys. Tulip alleged it would be relatively straightforward for the Defendants to write and implement a software "patch" to enable the Claimant to regain control of its assets – a point which the Defendants challenged as being inconsistent with the concept of a decentralised system, and which they claimed would in any event likely be ineffective and simply result in a "fork" in the network.
Tulip is a Seychelles incorporated company whose ultimate beneficial owners are Dr Craig Wright and his family, who are residents in England. The litigation has been the subject of a high degree of publicity, partly due to Dr Wright's (disputed) claim that he is Satoshi Nakamoto – the author of the Bitcoin white paper. The Defendants were said to be the core developers and/or otherwise in control of four relevant digital asset networks. None of the Defendants are based in England and Wales, although in May 2021, the Court granted Tulip permission to serve out of the jurisdiction. A number of Defendants issued a jurisdictional challenge concerning the order for permission to serve out, and the latest decision arises as a result of the Court's determination of that application. It is therefore relevant to note that, like many cases in the crypto arena, this was an interim application rather than a full trial.
To be successful in their jurisdictional challenge, the Defendants had to show that the claim did not meet at least one of the following criteria:
While the Court considered each of these tests for completeness, it overturned the permission to serve out on the basis that the claim did not meet limb (i) of the test. The Defendants therefore overcame a high threshold with the Court finding itself unable to conclude that Tulip had a realistic prospect of establishing that the facts pleaded amount to a breach of fiduciary and/or tortious duty owed to it by the Defendants.
In reaching its decision that the Defendants did not owe any fiduciary or tortious duties as alleged, one of the factors on which the Court placed weight was that the developers of the network software were a fluctuating body of contributors without any organisation or structure. It held that:
This is the first English Court decision considering the role and duties of cryptocurrency software developers, although we anticipate that this will become an emerging trend in the case law surrounding digital assets and smart contracts, with increased consideration of the intentions of contracting parties and programmers.
We think the decision in this case was unsurprising, but it is nonetheless reassuring for the cryptoasset and blockchain industry. No doubt we will continue to see claims being brought seeking help where eg private keys have been lost, or smart contracts have gone wrong, and the law will need to continue to adapt to respond – for now, the courts of England and Wales are continuing to showcase their ability to rise to the challenges that new and developing technology brings.
30 January 2025
22 January 2025
par plusieurs auteurs
6 December 2024
14 November 2024
par Tim Strong, Kate Hamblin
14 November 2024
par Emma Allen
8 November 2024
par Edward Spencer
30 October 2024
par plusieurs auteurs
15 October 2024
par Emma Allen, Andrew Spencer
5 July 2024
par Stuart Broom, Tom Charnley
21 March 2024
par Emma Allen, Amy Cheng
1 February 2024
par Katie Chandler, Emma Allen
12 February 2024
par Tim Strong, Nicole Baldev
14 December 2023
13 December 2023
23 October 2023
par plusieurs auteurs
17 October 2023
14 August 2023
par plusieurs auteurs
4 August 2023
par plusieurs auteurs
21 July 2023
10 July 2023
1 June 2023
par plusieurs auteurs
3 May 2023
par James Bryden
20 April 2023
par James Bryden
8 March 2023
2 March 2023
par Katie Chandler, Emma Allen
14 February 2023
13 February 2023
8 February 2023
par Jessie Prynne
19 January 2023
par Georgina Jones
3 October 2022
par Gemma Broughall
22 September 2022
par Ben Jones, Emma Allen
9 August 2022
par Nick Maday
25 July 2022
par Edward Spencer
6 July 2022
par Emma Allen
Welcome news for those pursuing fraud claims in the English Courts
28 July 2022
21 July 2022
par Edward Spencer
27 July 2022
par Stuart Broom
29 July 2022
par Jess Thomas, Lucy Waddicor
17 June 2022
par Stephanie High
13 June 2022
par Edward Spencer
26 May 2022
31 May 2022
par plusieurs auteurs
4 April 2022
5 April 2022
par Stephanie High
31 March 2022
par plusieurs auteurs
21 September 2021
par plusieurs auteurs
13 September 2021
par Edward Spencer
6 September 2021
par Stephanie High
2 August 2021
21 July 2021
15 July 2021
par Jess Thomas
26 May 2021
par David de Ferrars
5 May 2021
par Stephen O'Grady
21 April 2021
par Stephanie High
31 March 2021
26 February 2021
par Tim Strong
24 February 2021
20 January 2021
par Stephanie High
12 January 2021
par Tim Strong
23 November 2020
16 October 2020
23 September 2020
7 October 2020
par Nick Storrs
26 May 2020
par Edward Spencer
18 May 2020
par Katie Chandler
9 April 2020
par plusieurs auteurs
15 April 2020
27 April 2020
par plusieurs auteurs
21 April 2020
par Stephanie High
11 March 2020
par James Bryden
17 March 2020
par Stuart Broom
26 February 2020
par Tim Strong, Andrew Howell
21 February 2020
par Andrew Howell
2 June 2020
par Georgina Jones
16 June 2020
par Georgina Jones
2 July 2020
par Tim Strong, Georgina Jones
9 July 2020
3 December 2021
24 November 2021
par Stuart Broom
8 October 2021
par Katie Chandler
10 January 2022
par Tim Strong, Jess Thomas
20 January 2022
8 March 2022
par Jess Thomas, Lucy Waddicor
22 March 2022
7 April 2022
par Emma Allen, Georgina Jones
par Emma Allen et Georgina Jones
par Emma Allen et Georgina Jones