作者

Stephanie High

高级律师

Read More

Elizabeth Montpetit

高级法律顾问

Read More
作者

Stephanie High

高级律师

Read More

Elizabeth Montpetit

高级法律顾问

Read More

2023年12月4日

Disputes Quick Read – 5 / 86 观点

Court of Appeal confirms mandatory ADR is here to stay

  • Quick read

The latest developments in the case of James Churchill v Merthyr Tydfil County Borough Council [2023] EWCA CN1416

What was the situation before the decision in this case?

We reported in 2021 on the Civil Justice Council's report regarding mandatory ADR. One of the issues the report addressed was whether parties can lawfully be compelled to participate in an ADR process. The legality of this was considered by the Court of Appeal in Halsey v Milton Keys [2004] 1 WLR 3002. The Court of Appeal decided that the parties could not be compelled as this would "impose an unacceptable obstruction on this right of access to the court" The report disagreed with this and recommended that mandatory ADR be "encouraged".

What is the decision in the Churchill case?

The Court of Appeal ruled that the courts can stay proceedings to order parties in dispute to engage in ADR, including mediation. The key points were as follows:

  • It found that the comments made by Lord Justice Dyson in Halsey were obiter and therefore not binding on the lower courts. It also found that ordering compulsory mediation does not breach Article 6 of the ECHR, the right to a fair trial.
  • The court can lawfully stay proceedings for, or order, the parties to engage in a non-court-based dispute resolution process, provided that the order made does not impair the very essence of the claimant's right to proceed to a judicial hearing, and is proportionate to achieving the legitimate aim of settling the dispute fairly, quickly and at reasonable cost.
  • The court declined to lay down fixed principles as to what will be relevant to determining the questions of a stay of proceedings or an order that the parties engage in ADR. It acknowledged that a number of factors would be relevant including the nature of the process contemplated.

So what impact might this have?

The Ministry of Justice has already announced that it will be introducing mandatory mediation for civil claims in the County Court up to £10,000, starting with specified money claims. This is the first stage of a plan to progressively integrate a mandatory mediation step into higher value claims in the County Court. A new procedure has also been introduced in the Employment Tribunals of England and Wales allowing judges in complex claims to require the parties to participate in an ADR process.

This decision has now opened the gate to introducing compelled ADR more widely, including in more complex cases. The report of the Civil Justice Council recognised, however, that there are further issues to consider, including whether a mandatory process would be appropriate only in certain types of cases. We expect there to be further consultation on the matters raised in the report following this decision.

本系列内容

纠纷和调查

What are the litigation trends for 2024?

2024年2月1日

作者 Katie Chandler, Emma Allen

纠纷和调查

The use of AI in Trial Witness Statements post-PD 57AC

2023年10月23日

作者 作者

纠纷和调查

Failure to prevent fraud – a new offence?

2023年8月14日

作者 作者

纠纷和调查

CJC costs review – what will change?

2023年6月1日

作者 James Bryden, Helen Robinson

纠纷和调查

Embargoed judgments – dos and don'ts

2023年5月16日

作者 Stephanie High

加密资产、区块链和分布式账本技术

Disputes Quick Read: New obligations on cryptobusinesses to report under the UK sanctions regime

2022年8月9日

作者 Nick Maday

纠纷和调查

Disputes Quick Read: New gateway for serving Norwich Pharmacal Orders and Bankers Trust orders out of the jurisdiction

Welcome news for those pursuing fraud claims in the English Courts

2022年7月28日

作者 Emma Allen, Samantha Brendish

纠纷和调查

Disputes Quick Read: Care required when drafting SPA claim notices

2020年9月23日

作者 作者

纠纷和调查

Disputes quick read: pilot error?

2020年2月13日

作者 Andrew Howell

纠纷和调查

Disputes Quick Read: Dealing in crypto? Be careful what you call it

2022年4月7日

作者 作者

Call To Action Arrow Image

Latest insights in your inbox

Subscribe to newsletters on topics relevant to you.

Subscribe
Subscribe

Related Insights

纠纷和调查

Embargoed judgments – dos and don'ts

2023年5月16日
Quick read

作者 Stephanie High

点击此处了解更多
纠纷和调查

Recent investment treaty developments for the UK and Jersey

2023年5月11日
Briefing

作者 Elizabeth Montpetit 以及 Karel Daele

点击此处了解更多
纠纷和调查

Disputes Quick Read - What do practitioners think about making alternative dispute resolution (ADR) compulsory?

2023年3月8日
Quick read

作者 Elizabeth Montpetit 以及 Stephanie High

点击此处了解更多