Author
Lorna Bramich

Lorna Bramich

Senior Associate

Read More
Author
Lorna Bramich

Lorna Bramich

Senior Associate

Read More

5 August 2022

R&I Update - August 2022 – 5 of 7 Insights

UK government report on CVAs - landlords are broadly equitably treated but there could be improvements

  • Quick read

The Insolvency Service's report on the impact of CVAs on commercial landlords, particularly in the retail and casual dining sector, follows concerns from landlords that compromises are unfairly affecting them. The research was based on 59 CVA proposals. 

Key findings

  • Landlords are, broadly, equitably treated compared to other classes of unsecured creditors. 
  • However, the level of compromise for landlords was based only on the rent payable for the CVA period and did not account for other amendments, such as moving to turnover rent.
  • Key checks and balances are in place (eg appointment of the nominee and creditors' voting rights). 
  • The estimated return for creditors in the CVAs was better for unsecured creditors than the alternative (insolvency) procedure. 
  • Landlords can challenge a CVA by voting against the proposal, exercising a break option (a CVA cannot vary a landlord's right in the lease to re-enter its premises) or challenging the proposal in court. 

Improvements 

Changes could be made to provide greater clarity and improve stakeholders' understanding: 

  • CVA proposals could include: executive summaries, standard tables and post CVA balance sheets. 
  • The Statement of Insolvency Practice relating to CVAs (SIP 3.2) could include a requirement for prior consultation with the British Property Federation on behalf of their members. 

The exclusion of uncompromised creditors from voting could further address criticism around vote "swamping" although this would require further consultation. 

Key Takeaways 

While improvements to provide clarity and better consultation for creditors will be welcomed, the Report's limited suggestions for reform are likely to be a disappointment to commercial landlords. It remains to be seen whether further consultation will take place. 

Find out more 

To discuss the issues raised in this article in more detail, please contact a member of our Restructuring & Insolvency team. 

 
Call To Action Arrow Image

Latest insights in your inbox

Subscribe to newsletters on topics relevant to you.

Subscribe
Subscribe

Related Insights

Aerial view of railroad tracks
Restructuring & insolvency

Can a UK liquidator claim breach of duty against a director when the company has been fined for the same misconduct?

5 August 2022
Quick read

by Lorna Bramich

Click here to find out more
Empty red chair in the middle of green chairs in row
Restructuring & insolvency

When do UK company directors have authority to begin proceedings?

7 July 2022
Quick read

by Lorna Bramich

Click here to find out more
Road Markings
Restructuring & insolvency

UK special administration for a company subject to Russian sanctions

9 June 2022
Quick read

by Lorna Bramich

Click here to find out more