15 September 2020
The High Court has today provided welcome clarity on a number of uncertainties around business interruption claims.
While the court has reached nuanced conclusions, specific to each representative sample policy wording, it has agreed with the FCA on the majority of the key issues.
The court determined the outbreak of COVID-19 was the “occurrence” of a notifiable disease for the purposes of that cover where there were diagnosable cases in the relevant geographical area under the policy. Further, cover was not limited to outbreaks within the geographical radius.
The court, however, took a more conservative view on the prevention of access/competent authority cover, which is commonly taken out by hospitality businesses. The court found cover in some wordings but, in general, losses claimed under this clause will require a detailed review of the policy wording against the judicial guidance to establish precisely where cover applies.
On the key question of causation, the court determined that the pandemic and Government’s response to it were a single cause of the covered loss for the purposes of establishing the quantum of claims. This will be significant when determining pay outs under the relevant policies.
Commenting on today’s judgment, partner Katie Chandler said: “This is good news for the hospitality sector and the court’s guidance gives the clarity needed, which can now be applied to assist relevant policyholders with their BI claims. Not all policyholders will benefit though and it does all still very much depend on the detailed reasoning as applied to each policy wording, which fell within the scope of the FCA’s test case. UKHospitality members’ participation in this landmark test case has paid off and we’re pleased to continue to support UKHopsitality and the sector in this way."
UKHospitality Chief Executive Kate Nicholls added: "The confusion around business interruption insurance policies came at the worst possible time for businesses. They found themselves being denied support they thought they were entitled to in the middle of the worst crisis they have known. We are very pleased that this ruling, generally speaking, finds in favour of businesses who had taken out policies in good faith and may now have cover following the court’s guidance. Our sector is still on a knife-edge and needs all the support it can get.”
The Taylor Wessing team working with UKHospitality is led by partners Katie Chandler, Julian Randall and Richard Bursby.
by multiple authors
by multiple authors