Author
Dr. Christian Tenkhoff, LL.M. (UCL), M.Sc. (LSE)

Dr. Christian Tenkhoff, LL.M. (UCL), M.Sc. (LSE)

Salary Partner

Read More
Author
Dr. Christian Tenkhoff, LL.M. (UCL), M.Sc. (LSE)

Dr. Christian Tenkhoff, LL.M. (UCL), M.Sc. (LSE)

Salary Partner

Read More

18 July 2022

METAVERSE JUNE 2022/2 – 2 of 4 Insights

EUIPO: On virtual goods, non-fungible tokens and the metaverse

  • Briefing

The Office has released some guidance on the classification of items relating to "virtual goods" and "non-fungible tokens (NFTs)".

This is exciting news for any trade mark practitioner who has not been living under a rock for the past year. NFTs are a new form of digital asset. Using blockchain technology, they provide proof of ownership for digital or physical objects. And the Metaverse itself has been covered widely enough in the media so that it no longer requires an explanatory note.

The proper classification of virtual and NFT-related goods as well as other assets often associated with the Metaverse has been a hot topic of discussion for months. Different theories have evolved and been talked about at international trade mark conference and, of course, online. Will virtual goods simply form a sub-category of the IRL goods contained in a particular Class? Or should a separate Class emerge for products in the virtual world?

Perhaps not. The EUIPO's position, at least, seems to point in a different direction. The Office confirms that it will be taking the following approach:

  • "Virtual goods are proper to Class 9 because they are treated as digital content or images. However, the term virtual goods on its own lacks clarity and precision so must be further specified by stating the content to which the virtual goods relate (e.g. downloadable virtual goods, namely, virtual clothing).
  • The 12th Edition of the Nice Classification will incorporate the term downloadable digital files authenticated by non-fungible tokens in Class 9. NFTs are treated as unique digital certificates registered in a blockchain, which authenticate digital items but are distinct from those digital items. For the Office, the term non fungible tokens on its own is not acceptable. The type of digital item authenticated by the NFT must be specified."

Moreover, the EUIPO points out that services relating to virtual goods and NFTs "will be classified in line with the established principles of classification for services."

Based on initial reactions on social media, practitioners clearly appreciate the fact that the EUIPO has published this timely clarification. And while the classification of "virtual goods" in Class 9 will not come as a surprise, the EUIPO's view on NFTs will probably spark further debate (e.g. regarding NFTs tied to physical goods).

One thing is certain: properly classifying all the things consumers may or may not enjoy in the Metaverse will keep the Office and trade mark lawyers busy for some time to come. With the Office "increasingly receiving applications containing" the items mentioned above, tricky trade mark conflicts may arise in Class 9. After all, who is to say whether "virtual sneakers" and "virtual burgers" are similar?

The EUIPO's above approach (linked here) is set out in the 2023 draft Guidelines. Stakeholders are invited to submit their comments by 3 October 2022.

This article was first published by MARQUES on Class 46 (linked here).

In this series

Technology, media & communications

Venture Capital Trends: Web 3.0, DeFi, Metaverse and Tokens

Challenges and opportunities of blockchain technology to legal services

18 July 2022

by Dr. Niclas von Woedtke, MBA (Kellogg/ WHU)

Cryptoassets, blockchain and distributed ledger technology

Bits and pieces from the Metaverse

Issue #06

18 July 2022

by Multiple authors

Subscribe to our newsletter on the metaverse!

Related Insights

Metaverse

The Metaverse: brands, avatars and digital fashion - Part III (interdimensional infringement)

30 January 2023
Briefing

by Dr. Christian Tenkhoff, LL.M. (UCL), M.Sc. (LSE) and Inès Tribouillet

Click here to find out more
Metaverse legal developments
Metaverse

Bits and pieces from the Metaverse

Issue #19 | We keep you up to date with everything you need to know about the Metaverse.

30 January 2023
Quick read

by multiple authors

Click here to find out more
Brands & advertising

Licensing of NFT collections: The Moonbirds are released to the public domain. But why?

24 October 2022
Briefing

by multiple authors

Click here to find out more