Author
Paul England

Dr Paul England

Senior Professional Support Lawyer

Read More
Author
Paul England

Dr Paul England

Senior Professional Support Lawyer

Read More

8 January 2018

Inventive step in Europe and the UPC

January 22, 2018: Paul England: „Inventive step in Europe and the UPC"

Abstract
The author
Paul England PhD is a senior associate and senior professional support lawyer in the IP/IT group of Taylor Wessing, London, specializing in patents.

This article

  • The essential question that must be asked by a national court in Europe, when deciding a dispute about inventive step is ‘is the invention obvious?’, as required by Article 56 EPC. However, the approaches taken by these courts to answering this question differ.
  • The reason is that the question can be addressed in many ways, using different sub-tests and guiding factors. The proposed solution to resolving this inconsistency is the Unified Patent Court (UPC).
  • This article examines the key approaches and sub-tests employed in the major centres of European patent litigation—the EPO, France, Germany, the Netherlands and the UK—when attempting to answer the question ‘is the invention obvious?’. It assesses what common ground there is between them that may guide the future UPC.
Call To Action Arrow Image

Latest insights in your inbox

Subscribe to newsletters on topics relevant to you.

Subscribe
Subscribe

Related Insights

Capsule in petri dish
Life sciences & healthcare

Has there been a shift in how the European courts approach preliminary injunctions?

19 May 2021
Quick read

by Dr Paul England and Christoph de Coster, LL.M. (UC Davis)

Click here to find out more
Green stethoscope on grey background
Life sciences & healthcare

The UPC and Unitary Patent: April 2018 update

30 April 2018
Quick read

by Dr Paul England

Click here to find out more