Author

Emilie Kennedy

Associate

Read More
Author

Emilie Kennedy

Associate

Read More

7 April 2022

R&I Update - April 2022 – 1 of 6 Insights

UK court confirms where burden of proof lies in directors' duties cases

  • Quick read

In Re City Build (London) Ltd (in liquidation) [2022] EWHC 364 (Ch), the Court confirmed that the burden of proof in directors' duties cases, and in cases alleging a transaction at an undervalue, lies with the applicant.

Background

A litigation funder, as the assignee of the claims by the liquidator, brought proceedings against:

  • a director of two companies, alleging a breach of directors' duties in making certain payments, and that those payments were transactions at an undervalue
  • the two recipients of those payments, claiming one of the recipients was a de facto or shadow director (ie acting as a director but not validly appointed and controlling the board behind the scenes).

Decision 

The applicant failed to prove that:

  • The recipient was a de facto or shadow director. Where it is unclear if a person is acting as a director, that person is entitled to the benefit of the doubt.
  • The payments were "by way of gift or on terms that the [company] received either no consideration or consideration, the value of which, in money or money's worth was less than the consideration given away by the [company]". The Court did not agree that the recipients were required to prove that the payments were made for sufficient consideration. 

Key takeaways

In cases such as this, directors do not bear the burden of proof. Applicants must provide sufficient evidence to prove their case.  

Find out more

To discuss the issues raised in this article in more detail, please contact a member of our Restructuring & Insolvency team.

Call To Action Arrow Image

Latest insights in your inbox

Subscribe to newsletters on topics relevant to you.

Subscribe
Subscribe

Related Insights

Large Silver Pipes Stacked
Restructuring & insolvency

English Court recognises sole director's decision-making powers

11 October 2022
Quick read

by Emilie Kennedy

Click here to find out more
Fountain pen close up on peach coloured background
Restructuring & insolvency

English High Court sanctions Amicus restructuring plan

16 December 2021
Quick read

by Emilie Kennedy and Louise Jennings

Click here to find out more
Old and new office building facades
Restructuring & insolvency

New laws and code for UK commercial rent arrears – what can landlords do now?

11 November 2021
Quick read

by Emilie Kennedy

Click here to find out more