Author

Alexandra Prasch

Associate

Read More
Author

Alexandra Prasch

Associate

Read More

7 April 2022

R&I Update - April 2022 – 4 of 6 Insights

Payment of salary to employee by insolvent third party not protected from German claw-back claims

  • Quick read

Background

Under German insolvency law, employees are generally protected from claw-back claims. The payment of wages is considered a "cash transaction" if the employer pays the salary within three months of the work being performed. A “cash transaction” can only be contested in limited circumstances. Where a third party pays the salary, the cash transaction privilege remains if it is not clear to the employee that a third party made the payment (s.142(2) and s.3 InsO).

A recent German Federal Court of Justice ruling shows that this protection has limits.

Decision

A gift cannot be considered part of a cash transaction. If the payment of salary by a third party is a gift under s.134 InsO, the payment is not covered by the cash transaction privilege and can be reclaimed if the third party becomes insolvent.

The court also argued that it cannot be assumed that the legislator intended s.142(2) and s.3 InsO to be applied to an insolvent third party.

Comment

While this decision limits employees' protection from claw-back claims, the court noted that employees are only required to return payments they have been enriched by (s.143 (2) and s.1 InsO). It is possible for employees to argue that they have not been enriched if they used the remuneration for general living expenses and could not have met the expenses by other means.

Find out more

To discuss the issues raised in this article in more detail, please contact a member of our Restructuring & Insolvency team.

Call To Action Arrow Image

Latest insights in your inbox

Subscribe to newsletters on topics relevant to you.

Subscribe
Subscribe

Related Insights

Restructuring & insolvency

German court outlines requirements for insolvency avoidance due to wilful disadvantage to creditors

6 June 2024
Quick read

by Alexandra Prasch

Click here to find out more
Restructuring & insolvency

German Court rules on how to demonstrate illiquidity – key takeaways for directors

7 October 2022
Quick read

by Alexandra Prasch

Click here to find out more
Restructuring & insolvency

German court's first published ruling on COVInsAG

11 November 2021
Quick read

by Alexandra Prasch

Click here to find out more