作者
Tobias Rhode

Tobias Rhode, LL.B.

高级律师

Read More
作者
Tobias Rhode

Tobias Rhode, LL.B.

高级律师

Read More

2020年1月13日

Knowledge of insolvency in German exchange transactions

Background

The German Federal Court of Justice has constrained the scope of facts that can be used against a debtor by a creditor when making restitution claims.

Under German law, a debtor’s knowledge of their (potential) insolvency can be used as a fact proving the debtor’s intention to discriminate against other creditors. In practice, this has led to an abusive use of restitution claims by creditors, due to the excessive reach of this presumption.

Held

The ruling reduces the significance of the knowledge of insolvency in cases where the debtor has made a payment on the justified assumption that they will receive a benefit in exchange. However, the Court did not define a justified assumption, nor did it state whether the benefit received must be equal in value to the payment made, giving rise to new uncertainties.

Equivalence in value is not a requirement to prove intentional discrimination, but it can be used as evidence depending on the overall merits of the case. The language of the decision hints that restitution from the creditor is limited to the extent of the expected benefit.

Summary

The decision protects debtors and creditors who transact with debtors from restitution claims. However, due to the remaining uncertainties, it is still preferable to seek protection under the cash transaction doctrine. Whether the decision contributes to a general trend towards a more creditor-friendly practice remains to be seen.

BGH v. 18.7.2019 – IX ZR 258/18

Tobias Rhode

Call To Action Arrow Image

Latest insights in your inbox

Subscribe to newsletters on topics relevant to you.

Subscribe
Subscribe

Related Insights

重组和破产

New ruling reduces risk of clawback claims in a German restructuring

2022年7月7日
Quick read

作者 Tobias Rhode, LL.B.

点击此处了解更多
重组和破产

New developments on over-indebtedness under German insolvency law and impact on start-ups

2022年3月9日
Quick read

作者 Dr. Leonard Szabó 以及 Tobias Rhode, LL.B.

点击此处了解更多
重组和破产

New risk assessment obligations for German managing directors

2021年10月5日
Quick read

作者 Tobias Rhode, LL.B. 以及 Dr. Leonard Szabó

点击此处了解更多