作者
Jason Rawkins

Jason Rawkins

合伙人

Read More
作者
Jason Rawkins

Jason Rawkins

合伙人

Read More

2018年8月30日

Intensive use can overcome weak distinctiveness


Applicant's mark

Earlier mark

HPC POLO

POLO

This is another of a line of cases involving the POLO trade mark.

The applicant filed an EUTM application for HPC POLO covering class 18 (bags, etc) and class 25 (clothing). Ralph Lauren opposed it on the basis of its earlier EUTM for POLO, covering the same goods, relying on Article 8(1)(b) (likelihood of confusion) and Article 8(5) (a mark with a reputation and unfair advantage/detriment).

The EUIPO Opposition Division upheld the opposition on the basis of likelihood of confusion. On appeal, the Board of Appeal reached the same decision.

On further appeal, the General Court affirmed the findings of the Board of Appeal:

  • The marks were similar to an average degree
  • Because of its usage by Ralph Lauren, the POLO mark had enhanced distinctiveness
  • Taking into account the identical goods, there was a likelihood of confusion

One of the applicant's arguments was that the word POLO had weak distinctive character because of that word referring in several EU languages to a type of clothing, namely polo shirts. The General Court was unimpressed, confirming that any inherent weak distinctiveness was fully offset by the enhanced distinctive character the POLO mark enjoyed as a result of the intensive use and promotion of it and the public's familiarity with the name.

This is not a surprising outcome. The applicant's argument would work if it was using the term "polo" in its descriptive sense, in other words it could not be prevented from selling "HPC polo shirts".

Case Ref: Case T-657/17

Call To Action Arrow Image

Latest insights in your inbox

Subscribe to newsletters on topics relevant to you.

Subscribe
Subscribe

Related Insights

品牌与广告业

EU Community Design Right: must a design be first disclosed in the EU?

2019年11月1日

作者 Jason Rawkins

点击此处了解更多
品牌与广告业

"WILD PINK" and "PINK LADY" similar?

2018年11月29日

作者 Jason Rawkins

点击此处了解更多
品牌与广告业

Lessons to learn when it comes to evidence

2018年10月31日

作者 Jason Rawkins

点击此处了解更多