Authors
Callum Chamberlain

Callum Chamberlain

Trainee Solicitor

Louise Jennings

Louise Jennings

Knowledge Lawyer

Read More
Authors
Callum Chamberlain

Callum Chamberlain

Trainee Solicitor

Louise Jennings

Louise Jennings

Knowledge Lawyer

Read More

6 December 2022

R&I Update - December 2022 – 3 of 3 Insights

English Court considers whether a transfer of shares is good consideration to a validate a charge

  • Quick read

Re Bitumina Industries Ltd (in administration); Manning and another v Neste AB and another [2022].

This was an application by joint administrators for directions on the validity of a floating charge granted to a connected party at a 'relevant time' and seemingly invalid under s245 of the Insolvency Act 1986 (the Act).

Background

The charge was created as security for the transfer of shares to the company and was challenged by a creditor on various grounds, including that the shares did not constitute eligible consideration for the charge. 

A floating charge is not invalid under the Act if consideration is given for it at the time or any time after its creation.  Such consideration must consist of "money paid, or goods or services supplied". The charge-holder argued that the shares fell into the category of "goods supplied" and were therefore valid consideration for the charge. 

Decision 

The judge agreed with the charge-holder stating that the meaning of goods should extend to "things in action…and intangibles…which are of a kind received by the Company pursuant to its ordinary trading activity and have a clear value". As the company's business was in relation to the trading of shares, the judge found that the transfer of shares fell within its ordinary trading activity. 

Key takeaways 

The court was keen to avoid a restrictive meaning of 'goods' which would exclude a large number of types of property that are now used in everyday trade and financing. Both lenders and office-holders should note that this judgment extends the definition of 'consideration' and may lead to more charges being held valid as against companies in liquidation and administration.

Find out more

To discuss the issues raised in this article in more detail, please contact a member of our Restructuring and Insolvency team. 

Call To Action Arrow Image

Latest insights in your inbox

Subscribe to newsletters on topics relevant to you.

Subscribe
Subscribe

Related Insights

People modern spiral staircase
Restructuring & insolvency

Proposed EU Directive to harmonise certain aspects of insolvency law across Member States

11 January 2023
Quick read

by Louise Jennings and Callum Chamberlain

Click here to find out more
Old and new office building facades
Restructuring & insolvency

UK director automatically personally liable for company's debts

15 November 2022
Quick read

by Louise Jennings and Callum Chamberlain

Click here to find out more
Column Close Up
Restructuring & insolvency

UK Supreme Court's landmark decision confirms directors' 'creditor interest duty' works on a sliding scale

11 October 2022

by multiple authors

Click here to find out more