Insurance & Reinsurance Update - the "Double-Proviso" follow settlements clause - May 2010

The Commercial Court revisits the test

IRB Brasil Resseguros SA v. CX Reinsurance Company Ltd
Commercial Court, 7 May 2010

Not all follow settlements provisions are the same. In many cases, the reinsurance will be expressed to be "subject to the same terms, clauses and conditions as the original" and the stated obligation of the reinsurer will be quite simply to "follow the settlements of the reinsured". In such cases, the reinsurer is required to follow any settlement so long as: (1) the reinsured has acted honestly and taken all proper and businesslike steps in reaching the settlement; and (2) the claim so recognised by the reinsured falls within the risks covered by the reinsurance as a matter of law.¹ It is no defence for the reinsurer to show that the underlying claim, whether on its facts or in law, would have (or would likely have) failed had the reinsured defended it to trial.

Lawyers James Crabtree, Peter Kempe, Anthony Menzies, Dr. Gunbritt Kammerer-Galahn, Franz Janssen, Alain de Foucaud, Wolfgang Schaller, Dr. Astrid Wagner, Christine Flion, Christopher Dixon

¹   Insurance Company of Africa v. SCOR [1985] 1Lloyd's Rep 312 CA